10/30-11/5/2019
After visiting several places on the Little Tennessee River we started back down the 400 or so miles to Pickwick Lake and the turnoff to the Tombigbee River. We got to revisit several neat places we stopped at on the way upriver, and also visited several new spots. We still had a great trip. The weather was generally lousy, and we had seen much of this area previously, so I won’t post new photos of the scenery.
This post will focus on our visit to Dayton, Tennessee. Most people aren’t aware of the history in this place, but many may have heard of the things that happened here.
In 1925 the Tennessee legislature passed a law sponsored by John Washington Butler prohibiting public school teachers to deny the Biblical account of creation. This law made it illegal to teach the theory of evolution even though the state-mandated science textbook contained a chapter on this theory. The ACLU desired to challenge the law and advertised throughout Tennessee for a teacher to be a defendant in such a case. As a publicity stunt for the town of Dayton a local businessman, George Rappleyea, convened a meeting in Robinson’s Drug Store with the school superintendent and a local lawyer to find a local teacher to act as the defendant in this case. They convinced the high school football coach and substitute teacher, John Scopes, to admit he had taught evolution even though he wasn’t sure he had actually done so. That fact wasn’t really important. The situation rapidly spiraled beyond the limits of local control.
In July, 1925 the case was brought to trial. National media descended on Dayton, a town of about 2,000 people, to cover the trial. The best known media personality at the time was H.L. Mencken, a reporter for the Baltimore Sun, and he covered the trial in person as well as paying some of the defense’s expenses. National media had agendas in those days, just as they do today. The prosecution and defense legal headliners were William Jennings Bryan and Clarence Darrow respectively. Bryan was a two-time nominee of the Democratic Party for President, and Darrow was known as the most famous defense attorney in the country having previously represented the defendants in the Leopold and Loeb murder trial. This trial became known as the Scopes Monkey Trial because of the idea that man had evolved from primates, and because hucksters brought gorillas and chimpanzees to town, adding to the publicity and circus atmosphere.
The trial was held in the Rhea County Courthouse, with the courtroom shown in the first and second photos below. This is a large room at the top of the building, and is still in use as a courtroom today. On the day we visited court was not in session, so we were able to visit the courtroom. In 1925 air conditioning was not available, and when the July heat became stifling, and with the crush of more than 3,000 people in the courtroom, the trial proceedings were moved out onto the lawn. The third photo below shows where this part of the trial took place.
Of note, on the seventh day of the trial, the defense called William Jennings Bryan to testify as an expert on the Bible. This was, by far, the most interesting part of the trial, and there are several online references that discuss this cross-examination in detail.
In the end the defense asked the jury to convict Scopes so the case could continue in the appellate courts. The jury complied, and the judge imposed a $100 fine. The conviction and fine were later overturned on a technicality by the Supreme Court of Tennessee. Bryan died suddenly five days after the trial’s conclusion.
We visited the Scopes Trial Museum in the basement of the courthouse. This held several interesting items shown below including the sitting chair from Scopes’ boarding house room, the table from Robinson’s Drug Store where Rappleyea held his meeting, the mandated science textbook of the period, and the court records from the trial. These are all shown below.
One might think this case paved the way for evolution to be taught in public schools, but in fact that was uncommon before the late 1960’s. This trial failed to bring that to fruition. The Butler Act remained on the books until it’s repeal in 1967, but was never again enforced. Scopes suffered the awful effects of extreme publicity, and spent the rest of his life trying to hide from the public.
I found the role of Mencken to be the most interesting. He came to Dayton mocking the town’s inhabitants as “yokels” and “morons”, and referred to Bryan as a “buffoon” and to his speeches as “theologic bilge”. He did enjoy certain aspects of Dayton, writing “The town, I confess, greatly surprised me. I expected to find a squalid Southern village, with darkies snoozing on the horse-blocks, pigs rooting under the houses and the inhabitants full of hookworm and malaria. What I found was a country town full of charm and even beauty—a somewhat smallish but nevertheless very attractive Westminster or Balair.” To me this seems too close to the political situation of today with big city elitist candidates referring to half the populace as “deplorables” and “irredeemables”, and then blaming their nonelection on outside influences. Small wonder it works that way.
We are anchored tonight in a small cove at mile 220 on the RDB of the Tennessee River known as Caney Hollow. Tomorrow we will move to a marina near Iuka, Mississippi which is well known for quality maintenance work. We will stay there a month to have a home visit for the Thanksgiving holiday, deer hunting, and boat maintenance. I will not post the blog again until just before we depart in early December to travel down the Tombigbee River to Mobile.